2 Ingredient Peanut Butter Fudge is a long-time favorite in our house! Over the years I have made this fudge for bake sales, family gatherings and just to have around the house for a special treat. This post contains links to the products we recommend when making this 2 Ingredient Peanut Butter Fudge Recipe. If you buy through a link we make a commission from the sales.
Weight Watchers information for 2 Ingredient Peanut Butter Fudge
If you use an 8 x 8 glass pan you can get 25 servings of fudge that are 1.5 inches by 1.5 inches. Fudge is a rich sweet treat so a tiny piece will go a long way. Each piece would be 7 points on all three WW plans.
That’s why we do Weight Watchers so we can choose what to eat, when and how much. If you have the points and want to eat some fudge it’s your choice. Plus, if you make this to take and share at a gathering, they’ll be none left to take home. Trust me.
Can I make this fudge with any frosting?
First things first: this is a super simple and easy peanut butter fudge. It requires just 2 ingredients. If you’ve never tried to make peanut butter fudge because of all the work that is involved, now is your chance. I promise you’ll never look back! I don’t like difficult recipes in general. I’m not interested in spending all my time in the kitchen. I’m interested in spending time with family and friends sharing a meal and desserts that were easy to make. That is where this delicious peanut butter fudge recipe comes in; though it doesn’t last long…everyone loves it!
Can I make this fudge with any frosting?
I avoid making my peanut butter fudge recipe with either the cream cheese or whipped frostings. The fudge just doesn’t taste the same with those kinds of canned icing.
Have you tried making chocolate peanut butter fudge with just 2 ingredients?
I have used chocolate icing in the past, but I really prefer the plain old vanilla. I wouldn’t say that it tastes bad it just not my favorite. It’s certainly possible to make chocolate peanut butter fudge with frosting and peanut butter like this! I have been told by others that the cream cheese frosting tastes just fine to them too, so it’s probably my dislike for cream cheese in general that makes me think that the taste is odd.
Can I use flavored frosting to make this 2 ingredient peanut butter fudge?
You definitely can! Feel free to experiment with different flavors and tastes. Last fall we tried the maple bacon frosting with peanut butter and it was definitely a favorite around the dessert table.
Need a quick gift for the holidays?
This fudge is a perfect Christmas or any time of the year gift. I look forward to sharing it with the mail lady, Sunday school teachers, co-workers and anyone who drops in for a visit. Christmas is all about giving. Even if you don’t have a lot of money to buy for others a special homemade treat is sure to warm someone’s heart.
What kitchen tools do I need when making this homemade fudge?
When I mix up this treat, I always have a rubber spatula close by. You’d be surprised at how many extra servings you can scrape from a peanut butter jar or icing container with just a few swipes of a spatula. I’d have to say that the rubber spatula is one kitchen gadget I could not live without.
What size pan do I use to make your peanut butter fudge recipe?
My fudge is normally made in a 9 x 9 glass pan. I prefer one with a lid for easy storage and transport. I keep my fudge in the refrigerator. The glass pan lets me see what’s inside and is a perfect size for a nice thick piece of fudge.
Does this fudge recipe need to set up?
Yes! So it’s really easy to make, but it still requires some time to firm up. Once you are done mixing the ingredients they’ll need to go back into the fridge to cool down and set up. I find this is another area the glass pan really helps, the glass will more evenly cool everything down and speed the process up a bit.
Do you have any other dessert recipes I can try?
Can I make this peanut butter fudge in the microwave with sugar free icing?
I personally have never tried to make this kind of microwave peanut butter fudge with sugar-free icing varieties…that doesn’t mean it can’t be done 🙂 I’ve had readers try it and say that it works okay. If you are watching your sugar intake you can certainly give it a try. I would think the only difference might be the time it takes to firm up.
How do I double this easy PB fudge recipe?
This recipe is super simple. It’s a 1-to-1 ratio of peanut butter and icing. So however much icing you want to use, just use that much peanut butter to balance it out. If you want to simply double the recipe you’ll need to use 32 oz of peanut butter and 32 oz of icing.
Printable Easy Peanut Butter Fudge Recipe:
- 16 oz Jar of any brand peanut butter
- 16 oz Tub ready made frosting any flavor, I like the plain vanilla,the best but avoid cream cheese and whipped they don't get as firm
- Empty both the peanut butter and frosting into a microwave safe container.
- Microwave on high for 1 min. Remove from microwave and stir.
- Then microwave on high for 1 min and pour mixture into glass banking pan. (9 x 9, works best)
- Smooth out, then refrigerate until hard
Amount Per Serving Calories 190Saturated Fat 2gSodium 121mgCarbohydrates 16gFiber 1gSugar 13gProtein 4g